Keeley: Raspberry Rhapsody (8/10)

“I was a little scared to try this at first. I love raspberries and fruit, but fruit-flavored ice cream is another story. However, I was surprised by how much I liked it. There was a nice blend between the raspberry and chocolate flavoring, and the chocolate-raspberry cups in the ice cream made it 10 times better. It was sweet, but not too sweet for me. I would buy this again — especially because the prices are not too bad.”

Kenley: Peanut Butter Hearts Chocolate (8.5/10)

“Chocolate and peanut butter is forever a favorite for me, so I was quite excited to try this. I had high hopes and it did not disappoint. Although it was richer than I’d usually prefer, the chocolate ripple added a sweet balance to the slightly overpowering peanut butter flavor, and the peanut butter cups were my absolute favorite part. If you love peanut butter, you will definitely love this ice cream.”